SEO Title
ASRS Pilot Reports Relay ADS-B Pros and Cons
Subtitle
With more aircraft equipped with ADS-B, the Aviation Safety Reporting System is receiving more pilot comments on how ADS-B is helping to avoid collisions.
Subject Area
Teaser Text
With more aircraft equipped with ADS-B, the Aviation Safety Reporting System is receiving more pilot comments on how ADS-B is helping to avoid collisions.
Content Body

With more aircraft equipped with ADS-B, NASA’s Aviation Safety Reporting System (ASRS) is starting to receive more pilot comments on specific instances where ADS-B In played a role in collision avoidance.


For example, ADS-B provided situational awareness to a Cessna 172 pilot with respect to unannounced traffic at a non-towered airport. The pilots estimated the other aircraft, which was not talking on frequency, passed nearly overhead and about 200 feet above them. “Had we not seen him [on ADS-B], I believe he would have hit us,” the pilot wrote in the ASRS report.


A Cessna 182 pilot in IMC observed a conflicting aircraft on the onboard traffic advisory and alert system. Although ATC said the threat aircraft (a Cessna CitationJet) was going to pass well clear, the pilot said the ADS-B display indicated “maneuvering was required.” Upon landing, downloaded ADS-B data from both aircraft showed that although the Citation began a descent, it “briefly leveled off at 10,000 feet (our altitude). This happened just as they were passing our location.”


However, many ADS-B targets were displayed while one pilot transitioned Class C airspace in VMC, making it harder to discern threats. The absence of any traffic advisory resulted in a false sense of security “when an aircraft came directly head-on and passed underneath me probably 100 to 200 feet…ADS-B wasn’t too helpful there, because I was right over the airport and there were a lot of targets on the ground and in the air, so it was hard to make any sense of the traffic scope with the targets overlapping.”

Expert Opinion
False
Ads Enabled
True
Used in Print
False
Writer(s) - Credited
Publication Date (intermediate)
AIN Publication Date
----------------------------